Discussion about this post

User's avatar
James Barfield's avatar

Just read Susan below and I beg to differ. "They thought they were doing a good thing?" Holy Shit. That doesn't excuse it in any way and of course we should condemn the past and condemn the hell out of it every day. That doesn't mean we can't learn from it, it actually reminds us to do so. So Trump and Miller and the rest of them think they are "doing the right thing?" If I wasn't handicapped, I would be at the march on the 18th, like I marched against the Viet Nam war in 1968 when I was 17. I hope that since you live in DC that you will march for me, I'll be there in spirit. I thank you in advance.

Susan Bodiker's avatar

Forgive the contrarian view: but I really think we have to look at these events in context, not from our current sensibilities. The conquistadors were brutal, yes, and at the time serving the crown and god. They thought they were doing a good thing, and frankly treated their own countrymen with not much more compassion. (cf the Spanish Inquisition). They wanted rare materials not unlike the imperialists of the past 250 years. Or today. Condemning the past serves no purpose. Learning from it is what may make for better humans and civilizations. Genocide, slavery, oppression and exploitation are horrible and heartbreaking no matter who does it. Humans are cruel and xenophobic. Knowledge and understanding of the past will help us to do/be better (hopefully) in the future.

8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?